At my house, I kicked off November with a birthday cake!
![]() |
| A 6-inch yellow cake with chocolate buttercream frosting...it makes me think: "Birthday"! |
It's my husband's birthday later this month though that isn't exactly the reason for this cake (although celebrating early and often is a wonderful thing). I'll be making him the chocolate-hazelnut meringue torte for his actual birthday, as per his request, but maybe I've got birthday on my mind or I'm just constantly looking for a reason to celebrate and make a cake (plus, try out a promising recipe) because I just thought to myself...you know, it's somebody's birthday, somewhere! It doesn't have to be your actual birthday to pop a candle on it and celebrate!
Are you with me...or am I crazy? I think my family might think I'm a little nutty (my son sure gave me some funny looks when I kept insisting it was his birthday) but I hope you're with me, and I hope this inspires you to pop a candle or two on your next cake and let everyone around you make a wish before digging in. Why not!
For this "birthday cake", we're talking about a delicious yellow cake. I haven't had a lot of experience with it but I can now officially say that I have a go-to recipe for moist, fluffy, tender, flavorful, homemade yellow cake. And though I did not grow up eating yellow cake with chocolate frosting as my birthday cake (it was mainly ice cream cakes, then chestnut filled sponge cakes for me), I think of this combination as the quintessential American birthday cake.
This little 6-inch cake was very, very well received at my house. My son polished off as much as I would give him and was surprised by how much he enjoyed it. My husband seriously raved about it, which is a good thing since he is the upcoming birthday-boy. He says it's unlike any other yellow cake he's had but I'd argue that it is like the very kind of box yellow cake that we've somehow elevated in our minds. This is the homemade form of how we remember (accurately or not) boxed yellow cake to be. It's moist; it's dense yet light and fluffy, as well as flavorful with the taste of vanilla and rich eggs. It makes for an excellent layer cake in both texture and flavor.
Are you with me...or am I crazy? I think my family might think I'm a little nutty (my son sure gave me some funny looks when I kept insisting it was his birthday) but I hope you're with me, and I hope this inspires you to pop a candle or two on your next cake and let everyone around you make a wish before digging in. Why not!
For this "birthday cake", we're talking about a delicious yellow cake. I haven't had a lot of experience with it but I can now officially say that I have a go-to recipe for moist, fluffy, tender, flavorful, homemade yellow cake. And though I did not grow up eating yellow cake with chocolate frosting as my birthday cake (it was mainly ice cream cakes, then chestnut filled sponge cakes for me), I think of this combination as the quintessential American birthday cake.
This little 6-inch cake was very, very well received at my house. My son polished off as much as I would give him and was surprised by how much he enjoyed it. My husband seriously raved about it, which is a good thing since he is the upcoming birthday-boy. He says it's unlike any other yellow cake he's had but I'd argue that it is like the very kind of box yellow cake that we've somehow elevated in our minds. This is the homemade form of how we remember (accurately or not) boxed yellow cake to be. It's moist; it's dense yet light and fluffy, as well as flavorful with the taste of vanilla and rich eggs. It makes for an excellent layer cake in both texture and flavor.
You probably won't be surprised that the credit for this great recipe goes to America's Test Kitchen via their Cooking for Two cookbook. No matter if you make it for two or four, you'll probably just wish you had more of this cake and want to double this recipe next time. That's because they've done the legwork and pinned down the right ratio of butter to oil, the ideal amount of buttermilk and eggs needed to give us a homemade yellow cake that has all the light texture of a box cake but with all-natural flavors.
For the chocolate frosting, I went with my son's favorite from Beatty's (or Ina's) chocolate cake. I don't mean to doubt the folks at America's Test Kitchen at all but the chocolate frosting this yellow cake recipe was paired with called for double the amount of chocolate I used, as well as a lot more butter, and involved corn syrup. I bet it's delicious but, believe me, the chocolate buttercream I use is tried and true in our house. It is chocolaty and creamy. The beauty of pairing it with this yellow cake is that the contrast makes the chocolate frosting pop. It's worth every calorie as you savor the strong chocolate flavor against the moist vanilla cake. It made me understand why this chocolate-yellow cake combination is such a classic for birthdays, which are like the most important days of our lives (not that I'm being dramatic or anything).
For the chocolate frosting, I went with my son's favorite from Beatty's (or Ina's) chocolate cake. I don't mean to doubt the folks at America's Test Kitchen at all but the chocolate frosting this yellow cake recipe was paired with called for double the amount of chocolate I used, as well as a lot more butter, and involved corn syrup. I bet it's delicious but, believe me, the chocolate buttercream I use is tried and true in our house. It is chocolaty and creamy. The beauty of pairing it with this yellow cake is that the contrast makes the chocolate frosting pop. It's worth every calorie as you savor the strong chocolate flavor against the moist vanilla cake. It made me understand why this chocolate-yellow cake combination is such a classic for birthdays, which are like the most important days of our lives (not that I'm being dramatic or anything).
